Publication Ethic
Authorship Criteria | Conflict of Interest | Allegations of Research Misconduct | Correction and Retraction | Post-Publication Discussion
To maintain the quality of manuscripts and avoid publishing violations in the publishing process, the editorial board establishes the ethics of scientific publications. The ethical rules in this publication apply to authors, editors, peer-reviewers, and journal managers. The ethics of the publication refer to the provisions of the ethics of scientific publications by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Author Ethics
- Authors must provide information about the process and results of their works to the editors honestly, clearly, and thoroughly, and still keep their work data well and safely.
- Originality and plagiarism. The author must ensure that the manuscript submitted to the editor is original, written by him/herself, sourced from his/her ideas, and not copy the writings or ideas of others. Authors are strictly prohibited from naming the reference sources cited to the names of others.
- Repeated publication. The author must inform that the manuscript sent/submitted to the journal is a manuscript that has never been sent/submitted to other publishers. If redundancy is found in sending the manuscript to another publisher, the editor will reject the manuscript posted by the author.
- Author status. The author must inform the editor that the author has competencies or qualifications in certain areas of expertise in accordance with the field of publication science.
- Correspondent author. The author who submits the manuscript to the journal acts as the corresponding author who represents him/herself or the author team in terms of publication process correspondence with the editor and journal manager. Editors and journal managers only deal with a correspondent author of each article who is responsible for its content.
- Error writing the manuscript. Error writing the manuscript. The author must immediately inform the editor if found errors in writing the script, both the results of the review and edit. Writing errors include writing the name, affiliation, quotations, content, and other writings that can reduce the meaning and consequences of the manuscript. If that happens, the corresponding author must immediately propose a correction in the paper.
- Disclosure of conflicts of interest. The author must understand the ethics of scientific publications above to avoid conflicts of interest with other parties so that the manuscript can be processed smoothly and safely.
Editor's Ethics
- Decision of publication.Editors must ensure that the review process is comprehensive, transparent, objective, fair and wise. These are the basis for the editor in making decisions on a text, rejected or accepted. In this case, the editorial board acts as the manuscript selection team.
- Publication information. Editors must ensure that the writing guidelines for authors and other interested parties can be accessed and read clearly, both in print and electronic versions.
- Distribution of peer-review manuscripts. The editor must ensure that the review and material of the paper are reviewed, as well as the approval and clear review process of the manuscript.
- Objectivity and neutrality. The editor must be objective, neutral, and honest in editing the text, without distinguishing the business, ethnicity, religion, race, ethnicity, and author's citizenship.
- Editors must maintain all information properly, especially those related to the privacy of the author and the distribution of the manuscript.
- Disclosure of conflicts of interest. Editors must understand the ethics of scientific publications above to avoid conflicts of interest with other parties so that the process of publishing a manuscript runs smoothly and safely.
Reviewer Ethics
- Objectivity and neutrality. Reviewers must be honest, objective, unbiased, independent, and only stand for scientific truth. The process of studying the manuscript is done professionally without distinguishing the business, ethnicity, religion, race, inter-group, and author's citizenship.
- Clarity of reference sources. Reviewers must ensure that the source of references/citations of manuscripts is appropriate and credible (accountable). If errors or deviations are found in writing the reference/quote source, the reviewer must immediately inform the editor to be corrected by the author according to the reviewer's notes.
- Peer-review effectiveness. Reviewers must respond to manuscripts that have been sent by the editor. A reviewer must work in accordance with the time of manuscript review in two weeks. If additional time is needed to review the text, it must report immediately (confirmation) to the editorial secretariat.
- Disclosure of conflicts of interest. Reviewers must understand the ethics of scientific publications above to avoid conflicts of interest with other parties so that the process of publishing a manuscript runs smoothly and safely.
Journal Manager Ethics
- Decision making. The manager of the journal must describe the mission and objectives of the organisation, especially those relating to policymaking and journal publishing decisions without any particular interest.
- Freedom. Journal managers must give reviewers and editors the freedom to create a comfortable work environment and respect the privacy of authors.
- Guarantees and promotions. Journal managers must guarantee and protect intellectual property rights (copyrights) and be transparent in managing funds received by third parties. The journal manager archives and maintains articles that have been published at least in electronic form. The journal manager must publish and promote the results of the publication to the public by providing guarantees of benefits in the use of the manuscript.
- Disclosure of conflicts of interest. Journal managers must understand the ethics of scientific publications above to avoid conflicts of interest with other parties so that the process of publishing manuscripts runs smoothly and safely.
Authorship Criteria
JISE defines authorship in line with the ICMJE recommendations and COPE guidance. A person qualifies as an author only if they meet all of the following criteria:
- Made a substantial contribution to the design or implementation of the community engagement activity, data collection, or data analysis and interpretation;
- Drafted the manuscript or revised it critically for important intellectual content;
- Approved the final version to be published;
- Agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including its accuracy and integrity.
Non-author contributors. Those who provided only funding, facilities, site permits, technical assistance, or administrative support do not qualify as authors. Their contributions, including those of community partners, should be listed in the Acknowledgment section with their consent.
Contribution statement. Every multi-author manuscript must include an author contribution statement using the CRediT taxonomy (e.g., Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Writing – Original Draft, Writing – Review & Editing, Supervision).
The corresponding author acts on behalf of all authors, ensures that all authors have approved the manuscript and any changes to it, and serves as the sole point of contact with the editorial office during and after publication.
Unacceptable practices. JISE does not accept gift or honorary authorship, ghost authorship, or guest authorship.
Changes to authorship. Adding, removing, or reordering authors after submission is permitted only before acceptance. The corresponding author must submit a request stating the reason, together with written consent from all authors, including any author being removed. After publication, changes can be made only through the correction procedure.
Use of artificial intelligence (AI). Generative AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Any use of AI for writing, translation, or analysis must be disclosed in the Methods or Acknowledgment section, and the authors remain fully responsible for the content.
Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest exists when professional judgment about a manuscript could be influenced by a secondary interest, whether financial (funding, honoraria, ownership in a partner business) or non-financial (personal relationships, academic competition, institutional affiliation, beliefs). JISE requires all parties to disclose them.
Authors must include a conflict of interest and funding statement at the end of the manuscript, including any relationship with community partners or parties that benefit commercially from the activity. If there is none, state: "The authors declare no conflict of interest."
Reviewers must decline an assignment if they recognise the manuscript or its authors and have a working relationship, a collaboration within the past three years, a family relationship, a rivalry, or the same institutional affiliation as the authors.
Editors must not handle manuscripts involving themselves, close colleagues, or parties with whom they have competing interests. Such manuscripts are reassigned to an independent editor.
Manuscripts from editorial board members or Universitas Kuningan staff still undergo double-blind peer review by external reviewers. The editor concerned has no access to the process and takes no part in the decision. Articles by editorial board members are limited to one per issue.
Undisclosed conflicts discovered later are handled under the Research Misconduct policy and may lead to correction or retraction.
Allegations of Research Misconduct
JISE treats all allegations of misconduct seriously, fairly, and confidentially, following COPE guidance and flowcharts.
Types of misconduct covered include data fabrication, falsification or manipulation of data and images, plagiarism, duplicate or simultaneous submission, authorship disputes, undisclosed conflicts of interest, citation or peer-review manipulation, and ethical breaches toward community partners (e.g., publishing data or photographs without consent).
How to report. Anyone, including readers, reviewers, editors, and community partners, may report to the Editor-in-Chief at [email protected] with the subject "Allegation of Misconduct – (article title/DOI)". Reports should include supporting evidence. The whistleblower's identity is kept confidential, and anonymous reports are followed up when sufficient evidence is provided.
Procedure:
- The Editor-in-Chief acknowledges the report within 7 working days and conducts an initial assessment of the evidence;
- If the allegation appears well-founded, the editorial office requests a written explanation from the corresponding author within 14 days;
- The editor evaluates the response, with help from reviewers or independent experts if needed;
- If the response is unsatisfactory or the authors do not respond, the editorial office contacts the authors' institution for further investigation;
- The editorial office reaches a decision and informs the authors and the complainant.
Possible outcomes: allegation not upheld; written warning; rejection (if unpublished); correction; expression of concern; retraction; a ban on submissions to JISE for a defined period; and notification of the authors' institution or funder.
Throughout the process, authors are presumed innocent, and case information is shared only with the parties involved.
Correction and Retraction
JISE protects the integrity of the scholarly record following the COPE retraction guidelines. Published articles are never deleted or silently altered; every change is announced openly.
| Type | When used | Initiated by |
|---|---|---|
| Erratum | A publisher error (layout, editorial typo) affecting content or metadata | Editorial office |
| Corrigendum | An author error that does not invalidate the main findings (wrong figures, names, affiliations, images, references) | Authors or editorial office |
| Expression of Concern | Serious concerns about misconduct or data reliability while an investigation is ongoing | Editor-in-Chief |
| Retraction | Unreliable findings (fabrication, falsification, major error), plagiarism, duplicate publication, serious ethical breaches, or unauthorized use of data | Editor-in-Chief, authors, or institution |
Procedure:
- The corresponding author sends a correction request to [email protected] describing the error and the fix, with the consent of all authors;
- The editor assesses the request and decides on the action; suspected misconduct is first handled under the Research Misconduct policy;
- The correction, expression of concern, or retraction notice is published as a separate item in the current issue, with its own DOI, and linked both ways to the original article;
- For retractions, the original article remains available, but every PDF page is watermarked "RETRACTED" and the article page links to the retraction notice and its reasons;
- Metadata in Crossref, Garuda, and SINTA is updated accordingly.
Articles are removed from the site only in exceptional cases, such as a legal order or a risk to safety; even then, the metadata and the reason for removal remain visible.
Post-Publication Discussion
JISE welcomes scholarly discussion of published articles to maintain accuracy and encourage the exchange of ideas.
Forms of response:
- Letter to the Editor: criticism, correction, or additional data on a JISE article, up to 1,000 words and 5 references, submitted no later than 12 months after publication;
- Brief questions or feedback to the authors through the editorial office.
How to submit. Send to [email protected] with the subject "Post-Publication Comment article DOI", including your name, affiliation, and contact details. Anonymous comments are not processed.
Process:
- The editor assesses the relevance, scientific basis, and tone of the comment;
- Suitable comments are forwarded to the authors, who have the right to reply within 30 days;
- Approved letters and author replies are published together in the next issue, assigned DOIs, and linked to the original article;
- If a comment reveals an error or possible misconduct, the editor follows up under the Correction and Retraction or Research Misconduct policies.
Comments that are personal attacks, unfounded, or promotional are not published.














