Peer Review Process

JISE uses single-blind peer review: reviewers know the identities of the authors, while the identities of the reviewers are not disclosed to the authors. Every manuscript is reviewed by at least two reviewers with relevant expertise, at least one of whom is from outside Universitas Kuningan.

Stages and estimated time:

Stage Description Estimate
1. Submission Authors submit through OJS using the template –
2. Initial evaluation The editor checks fit with the focus and scope, format, and similarity (Turnitin); unsuitable manuscripts are rejected or returned 7 days
3. Peer review The editor assigns at least two reviewers; reviewer identities are not disclosed to the authors 14–21 days
4. Editorial decision Accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject 7 days
5. Author revision Authors revise and submit a response table addressing each comment 14 days
6. Revision assessment The editor (and reviewers, for major revisions) checks the revision 7–14 days
7. Copyediting and layout Language editing, typesetting, and galley proof approval by the authors 14 days
8. Publication The article is published in the scheduled issue with a DOI –

The average time from submission to first decision is about 1 week, and from submission to publication about 1–2 months.

Review criteria: fit with the focus and scope; novelty and urgency of the partner's problem; soundness of the implementation method; partner involvement; evidence of measurable impact (before–after conditions); link to the SDGs; quality of discussion; and currency of references.

Conflicting recommendations. If the two reviewers disagree, the editor may invite a third reviewer before deciding. The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief.

Appeals. Authors may appeal a rejection within 30 days by emailing the Editor-in-Chief at [email protected] with clear scholarly arguments. Appeals are assessed by an editor not previously involved with the manuscript, and the decision is final.

Confidentiality. Reviewers must keep manuscripts confidential and must not use them for personal advantage.